Quick wins for a faster PC:
The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →
ThatPainter is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More
Juventus’s 2017 identity is the most successful football badge redesign on this list: it turned the club’s initials, shirt stripes and Scudetto into a distinctive symbol that can stand without a wordmark. Manchester City’s 2016 badge follows, pairing historical references with an unusually extensive supporter consultation. The ranking weighs heritage, small-size legibility, distinctiveness, adaptability and supporter involvement; it is an editorial judgment, not an objectively measured league table.
How these football badge redesigns are ranked
A club badge has to do more than look good on a shirt. It may also appear as a tiny social-media avatar, on merchandise, or alongside other club identities in a crowded digital space. The ranking considers five things: how a redesign preserves or reinterprets heritage; how clearly its key shapes read at small sizes; how distinctive it is among football brands; how readily it can adapt across digital and merchandise uses; and what is known about supporter involvement or reception.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Recommended Free Tools
The assessments below are comparative editorial judgments, not results from user testing, sales data or a formal cross-club survey. Heritage matters because badges often carry place names, animals, lettering, ships, rivers and mottos—not just decoration. Recent changes are treated cautiously: supporter opinion can evolve, and the long-term reception of newer designs is not settled.
The 10 best football badge redesigns
| Rank and redesign | Heritage | Small-size clarity | Distinctiveness | Digital and merchandise adaptability | Supporter involvement or reception |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Juventus (2017) | Strong reinterpretation | Very strong | Very strong | Very strong | Reception not quantified here |
| 2. Manchester City (2016) | Strong restoration | Strong | Strong | Strong | Extensive consultation reported by the club |
| 3. West Ham United (2016) | Strong continuity | Strong | Moderate | Strong | Supporter consultation remains part of the club’s crest work |
| 4. Inter Milan (2021) | Strong continuity | Very strong | Strong | Very strong | Reception not quantified here |
| 5. Arsenal (2002) | Strong continuity | Strong | Strong | Strong | Long-term durability is evident; consultation evidence not stated here |
| 6. AS Roma (2013) | Very strong continuity | Strong | Strong | Strong | Consultation evidence not stated here |
| 7. Tottenham Hotspur (2013) | Strong continuity | Very strong | Strong | Very strong | Later wordless use noted by The Football Group in 2024 |
| 8. Atlético Madrid (2017) | Strong continuity | Strong | Strong | Strong | Consultation evidence not stated here |
| 9. Aston Villa (2024) | Strong continuity | Strong | Moderate | Strong | Long-term response is still developing |
| 10. Ajax (2025) | Very strong continuity | Strong | Strong | Strong | Too recent for settled consensus |
1. Juventus (2017): a crest reimagined as an icon
Juventus made the boldest break with the traditional shield. The club says the mark combines the black-and-white stripes of its playing shirt, the Scudetto and the letter J. That gives the design several recognisable links to the club while allowing it to function as a compact symbol rather than a detailed coat of arms. Juventus later described the ambition as an icon that could represent the club without words. Its distinctiveness and flexibility make it the strongest redesign here, even though this list does not establish a comparable measure of supporter reception.
#1 Best Overall
2. Manchester City (2016): history backed by consultation
Manchester City’s circular badge brought back historically meaningful elements in a cleaner arrangement. Its process is a particular strength: the club reported a 30-day consultation that included historical lectures and feedback from thousands of Cityzens. That does not make every design choice universally popular, but it gives this redesign unusually clear evidence of supporter involvement alongside its heritage case.
3. West Ham United (2016): a restrained update at a turning point
West Ham kept the shield and crossed hammers, simplifying the badge rather than replacing its central symbols. The change came as the club moved from the Boleyn Ground era toward life at the London Stadium, making continuity especially important. The result is less radical than Juventus’s, but its restraint helps preserve immediate recognition. The Football Group includes it in its ten-design ranking, and West Ham’s current crest work remains explicitly supporter consulted.
4. Inter Milan (2021): initials made into a compact mark
Inter’s redesign reduced the badge to a more compact monogram while retaining the club’s initials and black-and-blue identity. That is a practical response to the places a modern club mark has to appear, especially small digital formats. Its clear shorthand gives it strong adaptability, although the reduced form is a more restrained exercise in recognition than a wholesale visual reinvention.
5. Arsenal (2002): a durable cannon-led identity
Arsenal’s 2002 redesign established a cleaner, cannon-led identity that reproduces well and has endured as a modern Premier League mark. Its success is less about surprise than usefulness: the central symbol remains easy to identify, and the simplified treatment gives the club a consistent visual asset. The redesign year is recorded in the club-crest timeline used for this ranking.
6. AS Roma (2013): Roman mythology in a clearer composition
AS Roma’s 2013 redesign retained the she-wolf and twins associated with the club’s Roman mythology, while redrawing them in a more legible contemporary composition. This is a strong example of modernization through refinement: the story remains central, but the imagery is arranged to work more clearly as a badge. The crest timeline records the redesign year.
7. Tottenham Hotspur (2013): a cockerel that stands alone
Tottenham’s 2013 update made the cockerel and ball a stripped-back standalone mark. Removing supporting text can make a badge easier to recognize in small spaces, provided the remaining symbol is distinctive enough to carry the identity. The Football Group noted in 2024 that Tottenham later moved to remove words beneath the badge, extending that wordless approach.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Rank #4
- [Abstract Soccer]: Create a fun and active soccer design with custom text for a player you know.
- [Durable Material]: Made of sturdy, clear vinyl for a long-lasting and reliable bookmark.
- [Tassel Included]: Comes with a black fringe tassel that attaches to the reinforced, triangular header.
- [Double-Sided]: Personalization is printed on vinyl inserts placed on both sides for added flair.
- [Perfect Size]: Measures 7.5" x 2.25", an ideal size for a wide range of books and publications.
8. Atlético Madrid (2017): familiar symbols with sharper edges
Atlético Madrid’s 2017 redesign kept its bear-and-tree motif but gave it a sharper, more compact treatment. The change sought better screen legibility without discarding the imagery that makes the badge recognisably Atlético. It is a successful modernization within the club’s established visual language rather than a dramatic break from it.
9. Aston Villa (2024): a recent update still finding its place
Aston Villa’s 2024 redesign gives the lion and claret identity a clearer role across digital and commercial applications. Its inclusion reflects how recent club marks need to operate beyond the shirt, but the design has had limited time to build a settled history. Supporter response should therefore be treated as developing, not as a final verdict.
Best Value
- Package Content: You will receive 1 piece of soccer badge holder and 1 lanyard in the package. The holder measures about 11x6.8cm/4.33x2.68in and the lanyard is about 48cm/18.9in long, making it perfect for both work and everyday use.
- Great Material: Our soccer badge holder is made of good quality plastic while the lanyard is made of great polyester. They're lightweight, reliable, soft, smooth, resistant to sweat and water, and built to withstand wear, not easy to break, fade or damage.
- Stylish Design: The badge holder features a trendy soccer pattern, adding a sporty and eye-catching touch to your look. Perfect for soccer enthusiasts, it combines both functionality and style in one.
- Versatile Usage: This soccer badge holder and lanyard are perfect for work, school, hospitals, offices, events, or concerts. It keeps your ID, badges, or tickets secure while adding a fun, sporty touch. Great for everyday use or as a gift for soccer fans!
- Easy to Use: Just press the back with your thumb to easily insert and remove cards. With this, you'll never lose or misplace your essentials again.
10. Ajax (2025): strong continuity, provisional ranking
Ajax’s 2025 update has strong symbolic continuity and recognisability, which puts it on this list despite its short track record. That same recency is why it ranks provisionally at tenth: there is not yet a settled long-term consensus by which to judge its reception. The crest timeline records the redesign year; a higher or lower placement may become more defensible as the change ages.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Why modern football badges often become simpler
A club mark has to survive at different scales and in different contexts: embroidered on a shirt, reduced to a phone-screen avatar, printed on merchandise or used without its full name. Juventus, Inter and Tottenham show how a simplified symbol can carry recognition with little or no supporting text; West Ham shows that simplification can also leave a traditional shield and its defining emblems intact. These examples illustrate a recurring design strategy, not a rule that every badge should become a minimalist logo.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
The trade-off is between easy reproduction and the detail that gives a crest its local and historical meaning. A design can become clearer by reducing clutter, but a club risks losing distinctive references if it removes too much. The strongest redesigns here make that balance visible: they either preserve meaningful symbols in a cleaner form or build a new shorthand from elements already associated with the club.
Are modern football badges too minimalist?
Not necessarily. Minimalism is useful when a mark must remain legible in small digital placements, but it is not automatically better than a detailed crest. The relevant question is whether simplification improves clarity while retaining enough of the club’s identity to remain distinctive. Juventus’s J, Inter’s initials and Tottenham’s cockerel show how a reduced mark can work; Manchester City and West Ham show that historical references can remain prominent in a more conventional badge.
There is no authoritative published statistic establishing which football badge redesign is objectively best. The order above is a reasoned synthesis of design qualities and the available evidence about each process, not a measured ranking of fan approval or commercial performance.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
