ThatPainter is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More
There is no verified list establishing which five colors the headline refers to, or evidence that homeowners are divided over those specific colors. A separate designer-favorite roundup offers five Benjamin Moore whites worth comparing: Simply White, Cloud White, White Dove, Swiss Coffee, and Chantilly Lace. Their differences in warmth, undertone, and brightness help explain why a paint that looks appealing in one room may not feel right in another.
What the five-color claim can—and cannot—tell you
The five whites below come from Posh Pennies’ roundup, updated March 8, 2024; they are not a verified match for the colors in the headline. The roundup describes designer preferences and color characteristics, but it does not document homeowner disagreement or establish a ranking. Treat these as examples to consider, not a definitive list of five colors that all designers favor.
Paint names also do not guarantee a fixed appearance. The roundup notes that exposure and lighting can change how a white reads in a room. Its descriptions are useful starting points, not predictions of how a color will look in your home. Read the Posh Pennies roundup.
#1 Best Overall
- Ready to use, pre-mixed door and trim paint offers a fresh new look on interior or exterior metal, wood and fiberglass
- Water-based paint formula emits less odor and withstands fading for a long lasting finish
- Dries to the touch in 45 minutes, up to 3X faster than traditional oil-based paints
- Durable, chip resistant coating provides ultimate protection with modern curb appeal
- Beautiful satin door paint is available in 6 pre-mix color options for the perfect look
How the five whites differ
| Paint | How the roundup describes it | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Simply White OC-117 | Warm white with subtle yellow undertones. | Its warmth may be more noticeable beside a cooler white or in a room where the light emphasizes yellow. |
| Cloud White OC-130 | Warm and soft, with yellow and taupe notes; described as brighter and somewhat warmer than White Dove. | Compare it directly with White Dove if you want to judge the difference in brightness and warmth in your own room. |
| White Dove OC-17 | Soft warm white with gray and yellow notes; the roundup also mentions green undertones. | The mix of notes makes a real-room sample especially useful if you are sensitive to subtle shifts in white. |
| Swiss Coffee OC-45 | Creamy and warm; the roundup says its undertones may read gray, green, or yellow depending on exposure. | The article reports that designer Shea McGee used it at 75% strength. That is an account of one application, not a universal formula. |
| Chantilly Lace OC-65 | Crisp and bright. | The roundup says it can feel cool or gray in a north-facing room. |
Why a popular paint can feel divisive
“Divided” is not supported here as a measured homeowner response to these five whites. But people can reasonably prefer different results: one person may want a crisp, bright white, while another finds a softer or creamier white more comfortable. Even the same paint can appear different as the room’s exposure and lighting change.
That makes the choice less about finding the universally best white and more about deciding what you want the room to feel like. Consider perceived warmth, undertone, brightness, the room’s light, and whether the color will go on walls or trim. A color name alone cannot settle those questions.
Rank #2
- PAINT plus PRIMER: KILZ TRIBUTE is a low VOC, 100 percent acrylic advanced technology paint and primer in one formulated for superior hide and coverage with exceptional durability. Paint and primer covers light-medium stains and light-dark color changes.
- ADVANCED FORMULA: This is our most technologically-advanced acrylic product which combines paint and primer properties with exceptional stainblocking performances. This remarkable formula can be scrubbed clean safely. GREENGUARD Certified: low emissions of VOCs
- MULTIPLE SURFACES: KILZ interior paint makes a great wall paint or cabinet paint for many home improvement needs. Use on properly prepared coated or uncoated wood, drywall, masonry and cured plaster. Surfaces should be clean and free of dust, grease, chalk, rust and peeling paint. Mix well before using.
- SUPERIOR COVERAGE: KILZ TRIBUTE interior satin paint and primer covers up to 400 sq. ft. per gallon depending on surface texture, porostiy, and application method. If desired, recoat after 2 hours. We offer an 8 oz sample size for color choosing convenience. Use with high-quality brushes or paint rollers.
- KILZ has been making premium primers and paints for 40 years and leverage this experience in every gallon of KILZ Paint. Named Paint Brand of the Year in 2015 in the Harris Poll EquiTrend Rankings. Lifetime Limited Warranty (see label for details).
How to choose a white for your room
- Decide what you want to see. Choose whether you are aiming for a crisp, bright white or a softer, warmer one before comparing specific names.
- Compare likely candidates side by side. For example, the roundup describes Cloud White as brighter and somewhat warmer than White Dove, while Simply White is noted for subtle yellow undertones.
- Test the color in the intended room. Use a paint sample pot or a peel-and-stick sample, then look at it in that room’s light. Sampling can help reveal how exposure affects the appearance; it does not guarantee the finished result.
- Judge the color where it will be used. Check it on the wall if you are painting walls, and compare it with nearby trim or other fixed finishes. The roundup discusses wall-versus-trim use as a relevant distinction, but does not prescribe one of these five for either application.
Dark colors are a separate, current design conversation
A different question is whether to use dark, saturated paint. In an article published December 27, 2025, Homes & Gardens reported differing designer opinions about whether dark colors would remain fashionable in 2026. The article discusses dark blues, burgundy, deep greens, and charcoal, and suggests smaller or transitional rooms—such as foyers, powder rooms, and formal dining rooms—as possible places to use them. It also describes balancing darker areas with lighter ones. These are attributed design views and trend reporting, not measured homeowner preferences or universal rules.
Interior designer Hannah Blumenthal of Studio Olivine said, “While a new year always invites a fresh start, I believe that deep, rich paint colors are here to stay for quite a while.” Designer Roger Higgins of R. Higgins Interiors offered a different emphasis on composition: “You really need both dark colors and light colors to create balance in the home.” Those statements reflect the designers’ opinions, not an agreed forecast. Read the Homes & Gardens discussion.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- 【Multi-Purpose Water-Based Paint】: Vigorder white touch up paint requires no sanding, primer, or multiple coats—achieve a perfect finish in just one step. Easily refresh furniture, door frames, and other painted surfaces
- 【Strong Adhesion】: This white cabinet paint sticks firmly to wood, metal, furniture, cabinets, doors, baseboards, and more—one bottle covers a variety of touch-up needs
- 【Easy to Use】: The all in one paint comes with a brush. Clean the surface → shake the bottle → apply. One coat fades scratches, two coats provide full coverage. Wait 30 minutes between coats
- 【Safe & Eco-Friendly】: High-quality wood paint is durable, wear-resistant, and long-lasting. Free of harsh chemicals, safe for children and pets
- 【After-Sales Service】: If you are not satisfied with the white trim paint or if it leaks during shipping, please contact us—we will do our best to resolve any issues
Rank #4
- Use for a variety of indoor and outdoor project surfaces including wood, metal, plaster, masonry or unglazed ceramic
- Water-based acrylic formula is low odor, resist chips and provides long-lasting protection
- Covers up to 30 sq ft and dries to touch in 30 minutes for quick project completion. Paint/Stain Features: Washable, Waterproof
- Flat finish provides a fresh new look for surfaces, goes on smoothly and provides excellent hide
- Prior to application sand surfaces with 180/200 grit sandpaper, then wash with a degreaser, allow the surface to dry and apply paint
Rank #3
- Easy Renovation: Our innovative bottle with a built-in brush makes your renovation projects a breeze. No need to hire professionals, as anyone can use this fast-drying, DIY-friendly product
- Superb Adhesion: This touch up paint adheres to various surfaces like walls, trim, doors, cabinets, blinds, metal, windows, furniture, and appliances, enabling easy repair of scratches, stains, chips, spots, yellowing, and other paint imperfections
- Suitable for Interior and Exterior Use: Whether you need to touch up interior or exterior surfaces, our white paint pen is up to the task. It effectively covers and repairs imperfections on both types of surfaces, giving you a flawless finish
- Application Guidelines: For best results, apply at least two coats with a 2-hour drying time between each, ensuring the previous coat is fully dry
- DIY Color Adjustments: If you desire a custom color, our product allows for easy color mixing. Simply add our water-based paint special color paste to achieve the desired shade and unleash your creativity
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
